vlan agregation

  • 0
  • 1
  • Question
  • Updated 2 years ago
  • Answered
Hi,

I use BD10808 v15.1 as VLAN agregation switch. On 60 SFP ports I receive 1800 VLANs and uplink them to one server port. To setup VMAN i use only :

create vman sl1
configure vman sl1 add port 8:1-8:60

When uplink is connected to one of the SFP ports , all is fine. But if I use 10G (for ex. port 3:4) uplink stops working when I unplug and plug again xenpak( or fiber ).
When I unplug and plug it back, "show fdb sl1" or "show fdb port 3:4" do not show server's MAC address any more. If i make static fdb entry uplink also do not recover.
The only way to bring it back is to delete 10G port (ex. 3;4) from the VMAN and to add it back.

Can you tell me what im missing, or how can do this better?

Thank you
Photo of Ivan Ivanov

Ivan Ivanov

  • 120 Points 100 badge 2x thumb

Posted 2 years ago

  • 0
  • 1
Photo of Ivan Ivanov

Ivan Ivanov

  • 120 Points 100 badge 2x thumb
I did the following too: I put the uplink to one of the 1G SFP and one customer connects to xenpak on 3:4. dhcpclient didnt receive IP address until I changed primary ethertype from 0x88a8 to 0x9100. When I switch back the primary ethertype to 0x88a8 - client didnt work again even with static IP address on his network card. Sure I'm missing something regarding 10G-vMAN setup.
Photo of Ivan Ivanov

Ivan Ivanov

  • 120 Points 100 badge 2x thumb
Another workaround is to configure the vman (or 10G port) ethertype to another value and return back to required one.
Photo of Drew C.

Drew C., Community Manager

  • 38,546 Points 20k badge 2x thumb
Hi Ivan,
Are you still having trouble with this, or does your followup indicate that you've resolved your concerns?
Photo of Ivan Ivanov

Ivan Ivanov

  • 120 Points 100 badge 2x thumb
Yes, the problem is alive and need solution other than changing the hardware. So far looks like firmware issue, but can't exclude hardware completely. I test this only on G60X, 10G6X and 10G2H cards. Next days will have in lab BD8890 and will see. Have upgraded to latest firmware, but no luck.
Photo of Ivan Ivanov

Ivan Ivanov

  • 120 Points 100 badge 2x thumb
By this follow ups I try to be as much as possible helpful and objective to put this puzzle in order.
Photo of Drew C.

Drew C., Community Manager

  • 38,546 Points 20k badge 2x thumb
It sounds like this is a software bug.  Please open a case with GTAC so the issue can be further investigated.
Photo of EtherMAN

EtherMAN, Embassador

  • 6,688 Points 5k badge 2x thumb
If I recall there are nuances on how the 10808 handles vman traffic... Gut check on everything.  Jumbo has to be enabled on all ports you are doing a vman on both on the untagged vman ports and the tagged ports.  Also there was some of the 10 gig cards on the 10808 you could not have an untagged vman or vlan on the ten gig interface.... Primary ethertype for vman must be the same between trunking switches... and the 10808 if I recall used the ethertypes and vmans a bit different than any other switch moving forward.  We successfully run vmans through 10808 to newer 8900 or 670 G2 using ethertype 0x8100 as primary for vman... any ways hope you figure this out... 

* BD10K_1301_Fannin.1 # sh vman etherVman Primary EtherType    : 0x8100
BVlan EtherType           : 0x88b5
Photo of Ivan Ivanov

Ivan Ivanov

  • 120 Points 100 badge 2x thumb
Hi EtherMAN,

You are right about nuances, but also there are inanities.
Config is just fine - all by book. All ports are untagged, working like charm until I do the following steps:
- take the uplink fiber out;
- put the fiber back, link to shy;
- on server side i see the traffic comes from the uplink (for ex. icmp, port 67, 68 broadcast etc);
- the server sends coresponding packets, can see them outgoing with correct 0x8100 type and VLAN number;
- on customer port cant see returning packets;
- on uplink port I cant see fdb entry;

To recover from this state, only manualy (by deleting and adding uplink 10G port from/to vMAN config or by changing vMAN ethertype which probably refreshes something).

Today I'll put one mirror 10G port just to take a look from other perspective.
And next step is to put uplink port in tagged mode and to handle QinQ in the drivers.

Also is fact that there is a difference in behavior when ethertype is 0x88a8 and 0x9100 (in untagged setup this shouldn mater because there is no QinQ actualy).
  
I'll try the VLAN type 0x8100 too.