topic RE: STP topology changes in ExtremeSwitching (EXOS/Switch Engine)

STP topology changes

Tom_Taylor — Thu, 10 Aug 2017 22:20:00 GMT

I've been trying to track down an issue with STP in one of our branch offices, for some reason STP has an immense amount of STP changes logged;

i.e
Topology Change Detected: FALSE Topology Change: FALSE

Number of Topology Changes: 4974700

Time Since Last Topology Change: 42s

It's worth to note that we have a mixed environment with HP's and EXTREME's, does this config look correct ?
Stpd: s1 Stp: ENABLED Number of Ports: 46

Rapid Root Failover: Disabled

Operational Mode: 802.1W Default Binding Mode: EMISTP

802.1Q Tag: (none)

Ports: 1:1*,1:3,1:4,1:5,1:6,1:7,1:8,1:9,1:10,1:11,

1:12,1:13,1:14,1:15,1:16,1:17,1:18,1:19,1:20,1:21,

1:22,1:23,1:24,2:1*,2:3,2:4,2:5,2:6,2:7,2:8,

2:9,2:10,2:11,2:12,2:13,2:14,2:15,2:16,2:17,2:18,

2:19,2:20,2:21,2:22,2:23,2:24

Participating Vlans: Default

Auto-bind Vlans: Default

Bridge Priority: 28672

BridgeID: 70:00:02:04:96:51:b9:fd

Designated root: 70:00:02:04:96:51:b9:fd

RootPathCost: 0 Root Port: ----

MaxAge: 20s HelloTime: 2s ForwardDelay: 15s

CfgBrMaxAge: 20s CfgBrHelloTime: 2s CfgBrForwardDelay: 15s

Topology Change Time: 35s Hold time: 1s

Topology Change Detected: FALSE Topology Change: FALSE

Number of Topology Changes: 4974700

Time Since Last Topology Change: 192s

ON AN HP:
HP-2848-LA-CAR-R8-1# show spanning-tree

Rapid Spanning Tree (RSTP) Information

STP Enabled : Yes

Force Version : RSTP-operation

Switch Priority : 32768 Hello Time : 2

Max Age : 20 Forward Delay : 15

Topology Change Count : 405,614

Time Since Last Change : 4 mins

Root MAC Address : 020496-51b9fd

Root Path Cost : 22000

Root Port : 43

Root Priority : 28672

Any ideas?

RE: STP topology changes

Ram3 — Fri, 11 Aug 2017 06:06:00 GMT

1. Are we seeing any continuous port flaps between these switches on active port# 1:1, 2:1 ? If yes, did you try to eliminate the cable issues or any other symptom triggering the topology change?
2. Is it new implementation or any recent configuration/firmware changes made?
3. Provide us the "show configuration stp" and "top" output.
4. What is the current EXOS version and switch type?
5. Is there any suspicious logs generated in switch?
6. Did you configure edge ports?

The configuration on Extreme device looks fine.

The below link gives you the basic idea of configuring RSTP in Summit/BlackDiamond switches:
https://gtacknowledge.extremenetworks.com/articles/How_To/How-to-configure-RSTP-in-EXOS?_ga=2.148314807.1012568893.1502325830-1247773174.1501480829

The below link is for the user guide to EXOS and sample configuration is available for your reference: https://extrcdn.extremenetworks.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/EXOS_Concepts_Guide_15_4.pdf?_ga=2.171259424.1012568893.1502325830-1247773174.1501480829

RE: STP topology changes

Tom_Taylor — Fri, 11 Aug 2017 06:06:00 GMT

Thanks for this, out of interest is there any benefit to adding a designated root bridge? I disabled STP in our env for now and a ton of network issues have disappeared so I need to get it right when I re-enable it.

RE: STP topology changes

Emre_Kurtman — Mon, 14 Aug 2017 17:49:00 GMT

Hi Tom,

Please bear in mind that if the user ports of HP switch are not configured for edge port (or PortFast in Cisco terms) then each time a PC disconnects/connects you will get a Topology change. So you should configure edge ports on both switches' user ports.

Also, you can prevent the ARP entries from being cleared when a TC occurs by enabling iparp fast-convergence. Please see below article.
https://gtacknowledge.extremenetworks.com/articles/How_To/How-to-prevent-topology-change-impact-on-r...

RE: STP topology changes

Tom_Taylor — Mon, 14 Aug 2017 17:49:00 GMT

Right, so I only need to enable edge-ports on the ports workstations are plugged into and not inter-switch trunks ?

RE: STP topology changes

Andrew_Imam — Tue, 15 Aug 2017 04:23:00 GMT

Hi Tom,

Yes. You are correct. You will only need to configure the ports with hosts connected (Servers/PCs etc..) as edge ports and not the trunk links between switches.
Please let us know if you have any other questions.
Thank you.

Best regards,
Andrew

RE: STP topology changes

Tom_Taylor — Tue, 15 Aug 2017 04:23:00 GMT

Thanks Andrew, also any reason to specify a designated root bridge?

RE: STP topology changes

Matthew_Hum — Tue, 15 Aug 2017 04:23:00 GMT

You should always specify a root bridge, otherwise the system will determine a root bridge based off of MAC address and that can be unpredictable. all your nodes will block or forward based upon path to that root bridge, so usually it is place pretty centrally in the environment.