Hi,
Prashanth gave the most likely reason for this "issue".
This is the very typical problem people may face when adding a new node into an existing stack.
When you setup a stack with "easy stacking", the stacking protocol is set to "enhanced". If you add a new member, it will not be with the same protocol and thus you won't be able to add it.
Following Oscar's link is the best way to have no problem when dealing with stacking.